bg_image

ADDRESSING GENDER EQUALITY AND SOCIAL INCLUSION (GESI) IN GHANA’S RESEARCH & INNOVATION (R&I) ECOSYSTEM AS PART OF THE RISA PROGRAMME

In the interest of ensuring that R&I ecosystems are intentionally gender equitable and socially inclusive, the RISA programme is committed to understanding and addressing the various GESI gaps and barriers that arise within such ecosystems.

Some of the key GESI challenges in research and innovation include 

  • Underrepresentation of disadvantaged groups within R&I talent pools 
  • Ecosystem-strengthening efforts that often do not address, and can even exacerbate, existing inequalities and patterns of social exclusion
  • Lack of gender equality and social inclusion in Research

In Ghana, women face numerous barriers in terms of their ability to access, participate in and benefit from R&I ecosystems on par with men and others in positions of social privilege. Stakeholders in the Ghana context report a diverse range of gaps and barriers in this regard, including significant gender pay gaps, gender-based barriers to internal promotion and career progression, workplace discrimination, gender-based violence, financial pressures, and the considerable burden of unpaid care work that reduces the amount of time and energy women have available to invest in and grow their careers. In addition, low levels of knowledge and capacity related to gender equality and proactive inclusion mean that many institutions are neither aware of, nor intentionally focusing on, addressing these gaps and barriers within their organizations or approaches to their work.

As research and innovation are sectors which are historically and presently highly male-dominated, women are often not taken seriously when it comes to their knowledge, expertise or leadership capabilities. Stereotypes abound regarding women belonging to low-level positions, such as secretaries, and sexual harassment and exploitation in the workplace are common. 

As part of the recommendations made in the RISA report titled “Country-level Assessment: Ghana”, Heritor’s Labs has strategically committed to consulting directly with women and marginalized groups, to assess how best to respond to their needs and support their integration into R&I spaces.

Summary Report on Heritors Labs-RISA Fund Consultative Workshop on Gender Equality and Social Inclusion on the Theme “Addressing Gender Equality and Social Inclusion in Ghana’s Research and Innovation Ecosystem, held at the Ellking Hotel, East Legon, on November 29, 2022.

Background

Product development, research house and innovation services hub, Heritors Labs, in collaboration with RISA Fund, held its first in a series of stakeholder engagements towards the creation of an inclusive domestic research and innovation ecosystem in Accra.

The one-day workshop convened over forty professionals from the fields of STEM education, government officials, social organizations and researchers to discuss sustainable ways of addressing gender disparity in research and innovation with its related impact on the commercialization of research.

An expected outcome of the session was to collate the right inputs that will entrench gender-inclusive policy actions in the research and innovation space to push the broader agenda of research commercialization in Ghana.

Partnering with the Research and Innovation Systems for Africa (RISA) Fund, the goal is to deepen discussions and collaborations that will forge the right linkages for gender-based research and innovation systems.

Opening Session

The workshop was officially opened with remarks from the General Manager of Heritors Labs Ltd., Mr. Emmanuel Prince Amartey.

He mentioned that the workshop was one of the several target areas of the RISA Fund-Heritors Labs project seeking to advance research and innovation commercialization in Ghana.

Mr. Amartey indicated that the session was focused solely on gender equality and social inclusion (GESI) to identify and solicit first-hand information about the existing gaps in the research and innovation ecosystem in Ghana from persons with relatable experiences.

He was emphatic that the nation’s growth aspirations could be stifled by glaring inequalities in the research and innovation space.

Chairperson for the occasion and chief operating officer of the African Institute for Mathematical Sciences (AIMS Ghana), Ms. Adelaide Asantewaa Asante, in her acceptance remarks, affirmed the existence of inequalities against women and other marginalized groups in the research and advocacy space, which is largely male-dominated and women inclusion in that fields give dropping down the career progression ladder.

She admitted that there were systemic barriers against women and that the workshop was timely as it will bring to the fore key issues and recommendations that can be documented for subsequent policy actions.

She also shared instances of unequal access to basic infrastructure for female students pursuing STEM education in almost all tertiary institutions of learning drawing similarities of what existed over the last two decades to the present situation.

According to Ms. Asante, human capital development in the domestic research and innovation setup remain largely male-dominated because of certain conventional actions that do not favour women.

To buttress these points, she cited instances of a male lecturer being more likely to be called a professor whilst the female will be at senior research lecturer—even though they both entered lectureship in the same year and time—as well as the absence of favourable infrastructure for women and people with disabilities in the fields of STEM education and research.

She emphasized that workshop was both timely and important and commended the organizers and funders for helping to enrich the conversation around the issues of GESI in research and innovation and urged that the inputs from participants will be well-documented to inform policy interventions to tackle existing gaps.

Goodwill Messages

Chief Executive Officer of Heritors Labs Limited, Derrydean Dadzie, in his presentation, lamented the lack of deliberate thinking around the needs of the marginalized groups in society and the fact that there has been minimal action on commercialization research and innovation in Ghana.

To him, underpinning this problem is the inadequacy of investment in the fields of research and innovation from both government and private sector actors as most advanced economies have mostly thrived on making sustained investments in those fields.

In the 2021 Global Innovation Index Rankings, Ghana is currently ranked 112th with a score of 22.9, compared to its peer Singapore which is ranked 8th with a score of 57.8.

The statistics, according to Mr. Dadzie show that Ghana has not been audacious enough to catch up with its peers in terms of investing into research and innovation for growth and development and the project with RISA Fund was therefore to unwind minds and set the right focus on research and innovation that can help to transform the nation.

Other target projects of the Heritors Labs-RISA Fund partnership are: innovation commercialization, gender equality and social inclusion, capacity building projects, research and innovation communication marketing, standardization, conformity and assessment, industry-university research collaborations, research and innovation quality management, intellectual property and technology transfer and baseline and paradigm assessment.

Mr. Dadzie indicated that these thematic actions will be driven by digitalization, capacity building, stakeholder engagements and awareness creation, adding that a thriving research and innovation ecosystem would require the right support programmes, some of which already exist in the country.

Country Lead for the RISA Fund, Gameli Adzaho, shed some light on the activities and areas of focus for the fund where it instigates the right actions that promote inclusive growth and development across several disciplines.

The fund’s goal, he said, was to strengthen research and innovation ecosystems in order to intentionally drive development and trade, whilst commending Heritors Labs for driving the research commercialization deliberations.

According to him, the goal of pushing research for development will not be achieved without the participation of all stakeholders; not only gender but all aspects of inclusion.

The ideas and strategies from the workshop will be embedded into RISA’s decision-making with its various partner institutions and as a basis tool for advocacy engagements with government and other stakeholders.

Ms. Priscilla Hope, Project Manager at the Ghana-India Kofi Annan Centre of Excellence in ICT, who represented the Ministry of Communications and Digitalization (MoCD), enumerated on some of the policies of the ministry to promote digital awareness, adoption and protection among young girls in STEM education.

Notable among them was the flagship Girls in ICT programme which seeks to equip young girls with skills in technology and innovation.

She said the ministry remains committed to the gender inclusion and innovation agenda and that it was currently developing a digital economy policy that is hinged primarily on five specific components including digital skills and digital inclusion.

Ms. Hope assured of the ministry’s readiness to work with the two institutions to ensure the success of the project.

Director of Human Resources at the Ministry of Environment, Science, Technology and Innovation, Mrs. Cecilia Nyaabea, sharing in the concerns of the other speakers, said it was not appropriate to have the science and research fields dominated largely by men and encouraged women to bring their ideas and contributions to advance the country’s research and innovation ecosystem.

She said the ministry recognises the importance and implications of gender equality and inclusivity in the research and innovation ecosystem and has been spearheading the inclusion of women in every aspect of science, technology and innovation.

Bridging the agenda gap and ensuring inclusivity in R&I will not happen by accident but will require collective effort and responsibility, the MESTI official further emphasized.

At the policy level, Mrs. Nyaabea disclosed that MESTI is reviewing the current Science, Technology and Innovation Policy to incorporate gender-specific interests that will the inequality gap in STEM education and research and innovation.

To sustainably build the capacity of women, she disclosed that MESTI is forging the right linkages and partnerships. An example is the strategic alliance with the Human Resource Research Council of South Africa is an institution leading agenda and inclusivity project with the objective to develop a common but context-specific vocabulary of gender equality and inclusivity related items and concepts.

According to Mrs. Nyaabea broader goal of all these actions of the ministry is to have in place the necessary policies and programs to ensure inclusivity in the research and innovation ecosystem and for that matter, all other initiatives with the help of stakeholders to be able to promote gender equality and gender inclusivity across various fields of discipline.

Presentation 1: The finance Perspective of the inclusion gap

This paper, which was presented by Clara Arthur, Digital Financial Services Specialist with the United Nations Capital Development Fund (UNCDF), brought out the key issues affecting gender-specific interests in the financial inclusion agenda and proposed far-reaching measures that can propel access to digital financial services for women and other marginalized groups, especially in the fields of research and innovation.

One keyword from her presentation was “intentionality” which, to her, was the missing link as far as promoting equitable access to finance was concerned.

Ms. Arthur said there are some great financial policies to drive gender-specific financial aspirations in the country but what is lacking is the intentionality to look out for marginalized groups.

Also, the success of digital finance products including mobile money, digital loans and insurance services should drive actions that can get women to the forefront of the financial inclusion discussion by being intentional with funding assistance for women in the various fields of business and governance.

She further advised that marginalized persons should be particular about policies that serve their interests and deliberately pick out the areas of concern and take the needed actions, stressing that there are some opportunities that women are failing to take leverage.

From the presentation, some active measures to tackle the issues of financial inclusion across the research and innovation ecosystem included:

•Decrease the gender digital divide:  increase the number of women and girls that own a phone, can access/use the internet, and have the capability and autonomy to use it to empower their lives.

•Solve problems for women with digital and financial products: increase the number of affordable digital and financial products that address the needs and challenges of diverse segments of women.

•Lower barriers for women MSMEs via technology: leverage technology to increase access to finance and formalization of women-owned or managed small to medium enterprises (MSME). 

•Co-create a gender-inclusive digital economy leadership and labour force: increase the number of women in the workforce and leadership positions within the digital Economy Ecosystem.

•Increase women’s autonomy via policy incentives and data: support policymakers to use incentives and sex-disaggregated data to increase women’s digital and financial autonomy.

Presentation 2: Challenges facing marginalized groups in the R&I space

Assistant Research Fellow, Rachel Yeboah Nketiah, from the Centre for Climate Change and Gender Studies of the University of Energy and Natural Resources (UENR) shared the institute’s perspective on challenges facing early career women in the research and innovation space.

She emphasized the fact that there can only be real development through research-backed innovation.

She shared personal experiences of stereotyping and discouragement in her young research career where people tell her to quit tedious jobs and find softer ones that fit her as a woman.

Ms. Nketiah reiterated concerns about how child-bearing and care as well as other cultural and social prescriptions for women are drawbacks to gender equality and undermine women’s contribution to research and innovation.

She however urged women researchers to be focused and relentless by celebrating the small wins to become self-motivated and that they should know their field and speak directly to issues.

Key pointers from her presentation are as follows:

  • Women’s empowerment is one of the strategic tools for driving sustainable development. Many countries have achieved gender parity in primary education, but a significant gender gap exists at higher levels of education in most developing countries.
  • While the number of women graduating from universities with higher degrees is increasing, women scientists are grossly underrepresented in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM).
  • In developing countries, the gender disparity in research and innovation is a multifactorial issue that includes familial, social, cultural and institutional factors that cannot be ignored or overlooked.
  • Ultimately, lower representation of female scientists in science, technology and innovation fields translates into fewer female role models for girls and limited mentoring opportunities.
  • Challenging workloads both at home and at work can affect women’s mental and physical health and often due to inequity in domestic chores with partners, it reduces marital bliss.
  • High workload also affects work commitment and promotions, impacting women’s career growth and by extension indirectly discouraging girls from pursuing higher studies in science, technology and innovation due to inadequate role models.
  • The health of working women is more affected as compared to men due to the double burden of unpaid care-giving work and paid work; added to this is the stress of reduced chance of finding and keeping a job as a woman ages.

Consultative Session 1: Experiences and SWOT of GESI in Research and Innovation

This session was facilitated by Ohemaa Adjei Andoh, Founder and Director of Girls in Science and Technology. It was an experience-sharing and input-gathering segment of the workshop for participants to tell their stories of discrimination and unfair treatment in the various fields of work.

Participants agreed that corporate organizations, including multinationals, should have gender-balanced policies that give the right support systems to women.

They also attested to the fact that it is a tough environment but women in research and innovation must be abreast with labour laws to be able to strongly make their case in discriminatory environments.

A participant from the Mastercard Foundation, Nafisatu Yusif, was of the view that social conditioning has a way of preventing women from venturing into STEM and innovation.

Key outcomes from SWOT analysis

StrengthWeaknessOpportunitiesThreats
1.      Intentional funding support for womenUnfavourable workplace policiesA policy framework exists to guide the discussionPatriarchy—male dominance
2.      Increased advocacy and awareness creationInfrastructural challengesAvailable funding for the marginalized must be exploredStigma against women in certain jobs and persons with disability
3.      More affirmative action for women and physically challengedInadequate female mentorsFlexibility in research and innovationLack of access to higher education
4.      Global policies like SDGs that promote gender inclusionCultural stereotypes and social conditioningsMentorship and institutional supportPoverty—lack of resources
5.      Growing pool of role models with more women in leadership for others to look up toUnsupportive frameworkLarge pool of networkInfrastructural challenges for persons with disabilities
6.      Policies at national and local levels that support marginalized groups Social media for inclusivityKnowledge information gap
   Limited networking opportunities

Consultative Session 2: Charting the new paradigm: policy recommendations and stakeholder inputs

This session was facilitated by Ms. Charlotte Asiedu, an academic and sustainability consultant from the Department of Mechanical Engineering, Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology, to brainstorm ways to push gender equality and social inclusion to the new paradigm.

It was also an input-gathering session that asked participants to recommend concrete actions as steps in the right direction to achieve all the suggested ideas for the four main target groups: women, youth, micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs) and persons with disabilities (PWDs)

Key outcomes from the session

WomenYouthMSMEsPWDs
Favourable tax lawsFinancial supportThe need to strengthen partnerships and social networksClear inclusion strategies for persons with disabilities
Women’s inclusion in policy formulationPlatforms for mentorship and knowledge sharingInterest-free or low-interest funding productsAccountability—monitoring, evaluation and research and innovation
Affirmation action on policy for womenEducation, training and secondmentStructured mentoring opportunitiesA bottom-up approach to the decision-making process
Domestication policy to get men more involved in-home careOpportunities for partnerships Reinforce existing laws on the provision of infrastructure
Need to take advantage of existing opportunitiesAccess to opportunities in research and innovation space Awareness creation of existing laws and policies
Increased awareness creationFavourable tax laws for young people Capacity building–empowerment
 Access to information Sustainable support from government, private and social groups
 Protection of intellectual property Education and integration from school to industry

Closing remarks

Gameli Adzaho pulled the curtains on the workshop by giving a detailed reflection of what transpired and thanked facilitators, participants and government representatives for contributing to a successful stakeholder session.

The insightful information gathered from the workshop will set the tone for discussion on gender equality and social inclusion as far as the country’s research and landscape is concerned.

He said the solutions that were gathered from the session will not be implemented in a vacuum but would require all participants to act as agents of change to take the right steps for tangible outcomes.